GEIST:UPC Searchengine

ORD_598483/2023

NJOY Netherlands B.V. v. Juul Labs, Inc.

Date
2024-11-05
Division
Paris (FR) Central Division - Seat
Type of action
Revocation Action
Language
EN

Metadata

Case IDORD_598483-2023-e350b1d13eae
Case number
Registry numberORD_598483/2023
Order referenceORD_598483/2023
Keywords
Headnotes

Documents and full text

Extractor: pypdf | Pages: 37

1 DECISION of the Court of First Instance of the Unified Patent Court Central division Paris Seat (Section 1) delivered on 05 November 2024 concerning EP 3 504 991 B1 HEADNOTES: 1. An objective approach must be applied to the evaluation of the requirements of Art. 56 EPC (inventive step). 2. The reference to the person skilled in Art. 56 EPC is an element of this objective approach. Subjective considerations or the subjective knowledge and skill of individuals, like the named inventor(s) or the parties to the case , do not have an influence on the evaluation of inventive step. 3. The reference to the state of the art in Art. 56 EPC, which according to Art. 54 (2) EPC shall be held to comprise everything made available to the public by means of a written or oral description, by use, or in a ...