GEISTWERT Rechtsanwälte Lawyers Avvocati

UPC_CFI_337/2025

TCL EUROPE SAS v. Corning Incorporated

Date
2026-02-24
Division
Munich (DE) Central Division - Section
Type of action
Revocation Action
Language
EN

Metadata

Case IDUPC_CFI_337-2025-e829320e1b7b
Case number
Registry numberUPC_CFI_337/2025
Order reference
Keywords
Headnotes

Documents and full text

Extractor: pypdf | Pages: 44

1 Decision of the Court of First Instance of the Unified Patent Court Central Division (Section Munich) issued on 24 February 2026 HEADNOTES: 1. A realistic starting point is typically a prior art disclosure as a whole. Absent a specific reason or pointer in the disclosure itself (or based on common general knowledge) to do so, the selection of a particular example composition as a “starting point”, merely because it happens to come “closest” to the claimed subject matter in terms of structural components, bears the risk that such selection itself already involves hindsight. 2. Where the features of a patent claim, in an interdependent way, even if they are not synergetic in the sense of having a special combination effect, provide a solution to the objective problem, ignoring these interd ...