GEISTWERT Rechtsanwälte Lawyers Avvocati

UPC_CFI_404/2025 and UPC_CFI_405/2025

Edwards Lifesciences Corporation v. Meril GmbH a.o.

Date
2025-10-17
Division
Munich (DE) Local Division
Type of action
Generic Order
Language
EN

Metadata

Case IDUPC_CFI_404-2025-and-UPC_CFI_405-2025-a60a128fdae9
Case number
Registry numberUPC_CFI_404/2025 and UPC_CFI_405/2025
Order reference
Keywords
Headnotes

Documents and full text

Extractor: pypdf | Pages: 9

1 Headnotes I. An application for a cost decision constitutes summary proceedings (CoA UPC_CoA_618/2024, APL_57918/2024, para. 10). The judge -rapporteur therefore has broad discretion as to the procedure to follow (e.g. they can order evidence to be provided pursuant to R. 156.1 RoP, or may refrain from doing so), and as to the determination whether the claimed costs have in fact been incurred, and whether they are reasonable and proportionate. In this regard, the Judge -rapporteur respectfully disagrees with the findings of the Local Division Brussels in its order dated 25 July 2025 (UPC_CFI 131/2025). II. The extent of the examination of the reasonableness of the costs must be reasonable itself. If the value of the disputed costs is marginal compared to the overall costs of the proceedi ...